A PBS series revisits America’s penitentiaries and asks if punishment works

Lynn Novick’s four-part documentary premieres November 16 and asks an old question that is also a spiritual one: can a cell produce repentance?

What happened

The San Francisco Chronicle reported on a new PBS documentary under the headline “A new PBS series asks whether America’s approach to punishment works.” According to PBS, Crime and Punishment in America is a four-part, eight-hour series directed by Lynn Novick and executive produced by Ken Burns and Sam Pollard. PBS says it airs on four nights in a row beginning Monday, November 16, and will stream on PBS platforms for four weeks.

According to PBS, the series begins with public punishments in colonial America and moves to the first penitentiaries, starting with Philadelphia’s Walnut Street Prison in 1790. It then covers slavery, Jim Crow and the growth of prisons in the late 20th century, which PBS says happened “under both political parties.” PBS notes that reformers such as Benjamin Rush imagined what was called a “house of repentance,” where people who broke the law would repent and come back reformed. PBS’s own summary says the nation’s prisons “largely failed to deliver rehabilitation.”

PBS says the people interviewed on screen come from different sides of the debate. They include former police commissioner William J. Bratton, Manhattan Institute senior fellow Rafael Mangual, Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner, Equal Justice Initiative founder Bryan Stevenson and two former correction officers. According to PBS, the final episode centers on several people, among them a man imprisoned at 16 for carjacking, a woman sent to prison while pregnant, and two women who lost their sister to a high-profile violent crime.

In PBS’s announcement, Novick said Americans “have been debating the root cause of crime, the purpose of punishment, and the meaning of justice since colonial times.” The series has not aired yet, so nobody knows how viewers and critics will judge the answers it offers.

Our reflection

Picture the people from that last episode in one room. Two sisters still carrying a funeral sit across from a man who went in at 16 and a woman who was pregnant behind a wall. Their pain does not cancel out, and the system we built has rarely healed any of them. Grieving families get a sentencing date when what they need is an answer. A 16-year-old who goes inside still has to become a man, and he learns how from whatever that place teaches him.

The word that stays with me is penitentiary. The early reformers believed a person left alone with his guilt would come out repentant. They were right that harm has to be faced. They were wrong about where repentance comes from. Paul wrote that “God’s kindness is meant to lead you to repentance,” and he wrote it to people who were busy condemning others for things they did themselves (Romans 2:1 to 4). I have sat with enough young men in detention to know a cell can harden a heart as easily as break it.

That passage points at us before it points at any prison. Many of us feel a quiet satisfaction when a long sentence comes down, and we call it justice. Some of it is. Some of it is the anger Jesus said is already murder in the heart (Matthew 5:21 to 22), dressed up for Sunday. Bring that to God honestly while you watch. A country changes when its people repent of what they secretly enjoy.

Look at how Jesus dealt with the man all of Jericho knew as a crook. He invited himself to Zacchaeus’s house before Zacchaeus confessed anything. The repentance came after the welcome, and it cost something: half his goods to the poor, and four times over to anyone he had cheated (Luke 19:8). Mercy did not cancel the debt. It made him want to pay it. The people he had wronged were repaid, and a man was restored at the same table.

Change like that is slow and local. Our work inside juvenile detention depends on coming back, because one visit changes little. When a young person comes home, our re-entry mentors aim to stay beside him for twelve months, when the risk is highest and support usually ends. A church that watches this series together and then commits to one person coming home will learn more than eight hours of television can teach.

The series starts Monday. Let it move you to something you can do this week. The steps below are a good place to start.

God's kindness is meant to lead you to repentance.

Romans 2:4

Source: San Francisco Chronicle, “A new PBS series asks whether America’s approach to punishment works”

Previous
Next