Original reporting · The Washington Post
Most people who go to jail or prison were victims of violence first, study finds
What happened
More than 8 in 10 people in the United States who have gone to jail or prison were victims of violence first, The Washington Post reported, citing a study released Thursday by the policy organization Just Safe. The Post said the report draws on data widely used by public health researchers to examine a “victimization-to-incarceration pipeline.”
The Post told the story of Sheila Nared. After her father died suddenly, Nared told the paper, she lived through sexual abuse, homelessness, struggles with drugs and alcohol and years spent cycling in and out of jail.
In its release announcing the report, Just Safe said it used the Add Health study, which has followed more than 20,000 Americans since adolescence. According to the release, 84 percent of people who had been in jail or prison experienced violence before their first incarceration, typically at least four times. By age 18, 76 percent of those later incarcerated had experienced violence, compared with 47 percent of people never incarcerated. Just Safe said only 19 percent of incarcerated victims were ever convicted of a violent offense. “The people our public safety systems have failed to protect are too often the same people those systems later incarcerate,” Just Safe president Lenore Anderson said in the release.
The report asks lawmakers to fund trauma recovery for victims, protect survivors’ housing and jobs, and weigh histories of violence in diversion and sentencing decisions, according to Just Safe. These are recommendations and change no law. The figures are survey-based estimates of how often violence came before incarceration, and no critics of the recommendations were quoted in the reporting available to us.
Our reflection
I have sat in detention center classrooms with young men whose files are thick with what they did and nearly silent about what was done to them. This study puts a number on that silence. By 18, three in four people who would later be locked up had already been hurt. Nobody tended the wound. The first time the system really saw them, they were defendants.
A lawyer once asked Jesus, “Who is my neighbor?” Luke says he asked it to justify himself (Luke 10:29). Jesus answered with a man beaten and left half dead on the Jericho road. A priest saw him and crossed to the other side. So did a Levite. The one who stopped was a Samaritan, a man the listeners had been raised to look down on, and he bandaged the wounds and paid for the care.
We keep two lists: victims and offenders. Lenore Anderson’s line says what Jesus already showed that lawyer. They are often the same people. Many people in our jails are the man on that road, years later. We crossed to the other side, and then we came back with handcuffs.
Being hurt does not make harm harmless. Jesus said anger is already murder in the heart (Matthew 5:21 to 22), and the people a wounded person later hurts are survivors too. Repentance is still owed. But at the well in Samaria, Jesus named a woman’s whole history and offered her living water in the same conversation. Truth and healing came together. Our systems tend to bring the truth part only, and late.
Most of us carry a wound nobody bandaged, and it keeps making decisions: the temper you can’t explain, the drink at night, the distance from your own kids, the numbness you call being strong. The Holy Spirit puts a finger on that place to heal it. Let it be seen. The man on the road could not bandage himself either.
That 76 percent tells us when to show up: childhood and adolescence, before a record exists. Juvenile Community Violence Intervention is built for that window. Our JCVI work tries to reach a young person at first contact, often right after they have been hurt, with a credible messenger who has walked that road, and to stay through re-entry if it comes to that. Hospital-based programs meet young people at the bedside after a shooting. That work needs churches and neighbors willing to stop.
This week, be one of them. The steps below are small, and each one puts someone at the side of that road.
When he saw him, he took pity on him. He went to him and bandaged his wounds.
Luke 10:33-34
Your move
- Back the credible messengers who reach young people right after they are hurt
- Pray through Luke 10 for someone you passed on the other side of the road
- Mentor a young person in Miami, Chicago or Houston before a record exists
- Ask your state lawmakers what they fund for recovery after violence
- Bring your church into JCVI work as a partner
Source: The Washington Post, “Most people who go to jail or prison were victims of violence first, study finds”
